Apps & Mobile

Does The Digital Album Have A Future?

Ituneslp-logoGuest post by Aaron Tap (@aarontap), a guitarist, singer, and producer who performs and records with the likes of Matt Nathanson, Paula Kelley, and more.

Despite the shift to single-serve music culture, there remains a significant group of fans who want something more from their digital music. Listeners who yearn for a more tactile and immersive experience that helps them delve deeper into their music as if it were being served via an LP. To date, there have been some notable steps into the digital LP arena but an ideal has yet to be reached.

The first major entry to the field was the iTunes LP. Apple quietly unveiled their LP format in 2009 and its had just about as much cultural impact as their Ping service, which is a shame because on a basic level, they brought something pretty cool to the marketplace.

For the same cost as buying a full album on iTunes you get a mini-website within the iTunes framework by which you can view custom visualizations, artwork, and lyrics while the record plays. Many iTunes LPs also include bonus video content, which in the context of the LP seems to be more special than when they just offer a video as a bonus download.

The entire thing can also be viewed in full-screen mode, allowing for 100% attention to the experience. iTunes gets props for coming up with a decent, if a bit old-fashioned, LP solution but by a) limiting it to a relatively static DVD/self-enclosed website format and, worse, b) not creating a version for mobile devices, they have seriously hobbled its potential.

More recently, Spotify unveiled the Complete Collection plug-in. While less technically refined than the iTunes LP, this concept resonates a little more, as it relied less on flashy graphics than on simply displaying album art in an easy-to-use format that doesn’t require total immersion.

The Complete Collection is currently limited to just a handful of artists but they are adding new ones regularly. However, all they are really doing is digitizing existing booklets – some of them decades old – and the experience is weighed down by unnecessary, clunky skeuomorphs like page-turning graphics and faux page-creases to emulate an actual booklet. This is digital; don’t pretend. Innovate.

Also, navigation is a little sloppy. You should be able to click the large cover art to start playback, content doesn’t always load, and if you navigate away from the app while playing the LP, upon return you have lost the artwork and are sent back to the main app page. Still, as a basic version of a possibly addictive feature, it’s a good step.

Another approach is the individual LP application. Kristin Hersh released her last album, Crooked, as an iPhone and iPad app . There was a lot to love about this app, notably song-by-song audio commentary, essays, and a simple but effective swipe interface for checking out all the usual album info. As a value-added experience, this one is the most compelling among the LPs that I’ve checked out.

But, again, there are limitations: it’s not reasonable to expect that people will want to install an app for every record they buy, or even only for releases by their favorite artists. And if the digital LP is to be effective, expanded content will need to be wrapped up with a portable music format that is readily playable on all of a fan’s digital and mobile devices.

The potential for deep engagement is far greater on mobile devices, as people are more likely to be listening to music at an otherwise idle time and willing to dig into engaging details. If a music experience on a mobile device offered some of the visual interactivity of the iTunes LP or Complete Collection with the addition of a built-in browser and credits text linked to all and sundry external sites with the potential for limitless exploration, a majority of fans couldn’t help themselves from clicking and digging in, learning things they didn’t know they wanted to know.

The information is out there, whether it be from discogs.com, Wikipedia, or fan sites. And none of this need be limited to a full album purchase, either. It should be tied in with streaming services and with single-song downloads. And it’s a fact of the web that people can be inspired simply by clicking down a rabbit-hole of links.

Someone is listening to Def Leppard’s Hysteria and clicks on Mutt Lange’s name, finds out he wrote “Do You Believe In Love” for Huey Lewis, hates Huey Lewis but then learns that Huey played harmonica on an obscure solo LP by Thin Lizzy frontman Phil Lynott and says “fuck, yeah, I love ‘The Boys Are Back in Town!’” And suddenly this person is downloading the Jailbreak album.

It’s this kind of immediate response and serendipitous discovery process that will drive the development of a successful digital LP.

The fact that the digital music landscape is so volatile – with the old school bumping up against new technology on a seemingly daily basis and with music services rapidly coming and going – underscores the fact that an ideal has yet to be reached. Columbia records introduced the long-player in the late 40s, just in time for rock and roll to turn music on its head. With rock and roll in its dotage, it’s time for a new format that will enjoy that same kind of longevity and will engage and delight fans, from the casual to the obsessive, for decades to come.

Aaron Tap is a guitarist, vocalist, music producer, and overall sound-obsessed human. He spent years in the Boston music scene before relocating to Los Angeles with frequent collaborator Paula Kelley. He now records and produces in his own studio, QuailTop. When not making records, he tours the world with Matt Nathanson, The Paula Kelley Orchestra, Jesse Macht, and others.

Share on:

12 Comments

  1. Great article – I was not aware of iTunes LP – it will be interesting to see how things evolve. Remember that scene in the movie “Almost Famous”, when the sister left her box of records for her brother, under the bed… makes you wonder how that scene will look in the future…

  2. I can’t wait until all metadata for a song/album is available on Spotify or other streaming services. You can only click artist names now, but imagine if you could click the mixing engineers name and see everything they’ve mixed. Credits need to be available in digital for discovery purposes and so the people that work on all this music get the credit they deserve.

  3. Aaron, great post. The slow-going Connected Media Experience (.com) is an industry standard that’s attempting to enable what you want.

  4. While it’s great to have recap on iTunes LP and other services, I believe music listening needs to be increasingly separated from screen-based “immersion” on “devices”. It’s music after all. The enjoyment and immersion should come in via the ears.

  5. Good point in a broad sense. However, is a HiFi not a “device?” As music-makers, it’s a difficult path to take to not live in the present. My suggestions are geared towards the idea of using technology to draw people’s ears back to the music. Sometimes it takes other stimuli to make that happen. My enjoyment of Shostakovich’s 10th Symphony was greatly heightened by reading about the conditions under which he wrote it, for example. While reclining, eyes closed, dedicating oneself to a performance is a glorious experience, music does not exist in a vacuum. There are many ways to listen.

  6. I’m so glad I made a cassette 20 years ago, remastered it for CD 10 years ago, never made that CD and cut straight to its 20th Anniversary DIGITAL-only Re-Release…just this past week!! Now ya tell me Aaron!! I put a 6 minute documentary on a Live “enhanced” CD 10 years ago and it ended up on YouTube, so making things simple and letting the people ride down the rabbit hole of discovery on their own time sounds about right. xoLG

  7. great post.
    the ‘rabbit hole of links’ is what led me to you and PK and is responsible for much of my new musical knowledge (and lots of other knowledge of questionable value)
    I was on a trans-Atlantic flight last week and was driven nearly insane because I needed to know who was drumming on a certain track. The lack of instant gratification led to a unique form of anxiety!
    I’m confident (hopeful?) that an elegant solution will evolve soon.

  8. I understand your perspective. Yes, a HiFi is a device but of course generally does not revolve around a screen. I was lamenting increasing lack of separation of music listening from a screen-based environment, largely due to the ever-present calls to other distractions when listening is taking place in front of visual stimulation.

  9. You are not incorrect, of course. I think the separation has always existed in other forms. It’s up to us as artists to figure out how to best engage listeners given the tools at our disposal and, for better or worse, given the landscape at any given point in history. Ultimately, yes, I would like to preserve more of the experience you espouse. But what I’d also like to see is a more concerted harnessing of the technology for the power of art, rather than tech for tech’s – or worse – sake.

Comments are closed.