> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.hypebot.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# 'How Culture Moves in the Age of Algorithm' - David Macias
- URL: https://www.hypebot.com/how-culture-moves-in-the-age-of-algorithm-david-macias/
- Published: 2026-11-16T14:23:48.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T14:23:48.000Z
- Description: An exclusive advance chapter from Thirty Tiger's David Macias book examining the algorithms that determine which songs and stories reach us.
- Author: Guest Author
- Tags: Book Excerpt, #coverstory, Thirty Tigers, David Macias, Circulation, algorithms, music marketing, music industry, Music Business, Music Streaming

### "Not the hype, not the panic. The mechanics. How does a recommendation system choose what an audience gets to hear? And who does it leave out?"

---

**DAVID MACIAS:** *In 2012, we were all trying to figure out whether *Spotify* would be a boon for the music business or its ruination. I don't even remember how *Bruce Houghton* and I connected, but he gave me a forum to say my piece: that it would be much more the former than the latter, and I think it's basically turned out that way.* 

**Bob Lefsetz* was kind enough to pick up the Hypebot piece and share it with his enormous audience. That piece changed things for *Thirty Tigers* and me, and I remain very grateful for the opportunity that Bruce and the Hypebot team gave me 14 years ago.*

*So here we find ourselves in 2026 with a growing problem, at least from my vantage point. It's not quantifiable (yet), but I think we all feel it. We keep signing the same types of acts; we are all waiting for the same cues in the marketplace, and it's creating a music culture that is increasingly bereft of the dynamism and friction that propel the business toward the next exciting scene. Our industry has essentially become an ouroboros, and I felt like, as I did in 2012, I better figure some shit out, or I should just pack it in. And I love music too much to just give up.The "figuring shit out" culminated in a book (called *Circulation: How Culture Moves in the Age of Algorithm)* that I am proud to share a chapter from. Chapter Five, to be precise.* 

*It tells of my experience with *Afropunk*, why IRL spaces for emerging music communities are essential, and how vital it is for an emerging music scene to see its values amplified, celebrated, and protected, if it is to take root. You can find the introduction and the first four chapters on* [*Substack*](https://circulationbook.substack.com/) *(no paywall), and it will be in bookstores on January 14th. Enjoy, and again, thank you to Bruce and the entire Hypebot team.*

---

[***Circulation: How Culture Moves in the Age of Algorithm***](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1918661707?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRedirect=mhFallback&ref=hypebot.com)***,*** the upcomig book from author and Co-Founder/President of Thirty Tigers, **David Macias,** is out January 14 via Whitefox Publishing. 

**Hypebot is honored to share this exclusive unabridged chapter from one of the modern music industry's most perceptive and innovative voices.**

## **Chapter Five**

It was two weeks after Michael Brown had been killed in Ferguson, Missouri, and I was standing in a field at the Afropunk Festival in Brooklyn, waiting for D’Angelo to begin his headline set on the last night of the festival.

The emotion was open and raw. The grief. The fear. The anger. The exhaustion from a disappointment that never relents. I felt all those things, but I also felt conflicted about whether I deserved to feel them. I felt strange about being there at all. I felt like an interloper in someone else’s collective grief. And who gives a shit about how I was feeling anyway?

However, as I wandered around the festival grounds, I was met with kindness. I thought about the sign I had walked past at the entrance to the festival:

No Sexism  
No Racism  
No Ableism  
No Ageism  
No Homophobia  
No Fatphobia  
No Transphobia  
No Hatefulness

It sent a clear signal. The price of admission included understanding that you had to comport yourself within a certain value system if you wanted to hang out in this cool-ass space. I was the outsider. I was from the community that had created the conditions that took another young Black man’s life. Yet I still felt the love and respect that festival co-owners and organizers Jocelyn Cooper and Matthew Morgan insisted upon for everyone. Everyone else had read that sign too.

D’Angelo opened his set with Bob Marley’s “Burnin’ and Lootin’,” and it was electric. Marley had written the song while the poor Jamaican communities he came from were enduring brutal police raids and harassment that cost some of his neighbors their lives. When D’Angelo kicked into the song that night, the time and space between Marley’s Jamaica and two weeks ago collapsed into the present moment. The feeling in the crowd shifted. Defiant. Foreboding. Smoldering. It remains one of the most indelible moments of my life as a music fan.

I had first heard about the Afropunk Festival while attending TSU, but beyond that, it seemed, from the vantage point of a white Southern refugee from the country music business, like an interesting cultural artifact to know about. I left TSU with a degree in political science and the hope of continuing my journey with the Black community. I actively looked for opportunities to work with Black artists through Thirty Tigers, but had little idea of how to make that happen.

That opportunity presented itself when I began discussing a potential working relationship with singer Alice Smith, which culminated in our release of her album She, which remains one of my favorite records we have ever released. She was playing the Afropunk Festival in 2012, so I hopped on a plane and went to Brooklyn to meet her. What I encountered there shifted me on my axis.

My education had helped me grow more comfortable listening to Black stories and become more knowledgeable about them. But suddenly I found myself standing in a park in Brooklyn surrounded by people who were masters at telling their stories, not only through music, but through fashion, visual art, and food. Just being there made me feel cooler. It was the spirit that permeated the event, though, that turned it from merely the coolest thing I had experienced in some time into something truly meaningful. There were those signs you walked past at every entrance to the festival. You literally could not get in without walking past them. They put you on loving notice that you were expected to show up in love as well.

Think about what that must have meant to these talented young people - Black, queer, nerdy, or otherwise “other” in some way - to have a place where they could relax in the knowledge that this festival existed to honor them. What they thought. How they felt. How they saw the world.

You could go home to your conservative family over the holidays and, though you loved them, know they would never fully understand or accept you. But here you could feel, viscerally, that there was a place for you somewhere. Brooklyn. With seventy thousand of your friends. Just knowing there were people who looked and felt like you made the rest of the world more bearable.

Sociologist Sherry Turkle has written extensively about the differences between relationships formed in person and those formed online, most notably in her book Alone Together. Turkle observed that part of the allure of digital media is that it lets us carefully craft what we say and control the timing of our communication. We present curated versions of ourselves.

The more invested we become in maintaining those curated identities, the higher the perceived cost of revealing our authentic selves. Communication becomes efficient but thinner.

As we habituate to the convenience and safety of online interaction, our ability to read and respond to the signals that guide face-to-face connection - body language, emotional ambiguity, disagreement - begins to weaken. Over time, this can lead to alienation and loneliness born from never allowing our authentic selves to be fully seen.

Another important insight from Turkle’s work is that reduced face-to-face interaction correlates with lower empathy scores. She argues that empathy is a skill developed through practice in direct human relationships. Empathy is possible online, but it’s less likely to develop the same way because digital environments often reduce the friction we encounter in the real world.

And friction matters. Synthesis requires not only a thesis, but an antithesis as well. Algorithms, at the extremes, offer thesis with no chance of antithesis.

Cooper and Morgan created a community where celebrating - or at least tolerating - the other was very much the point. They invited artists who were outsiders, attracted audiences who were outsiders, and encouraged everyone to show up and be their authentic selves. It was a declaration to the world: I don’t care who you are. If you are brave enough to show up authentically, you will be held. The values of this house are non-negotiable, and one of them is “heldness”.

In his landmark book The City in History, twentieth-century historian and sociologist Lewis Mumford describes the city as a theater of social action. Cities have long been understood as centers of commerce, industry, and administration. Mumford believed something deeper was happening. Cities teem with encounters between individuals and different cultures. The proximity and density of people and ideas accelerate the spread of things not yet fully formed: solutions looking for problems, aesthetics looking for communities.

Understanding the mechanism behind that acceleration matters, because it is the same mechanism that makes a festival like Afropunk possible and important. Density works in cities the way it works in physics. More particles in a confined space means more collisions, and more collisions mean more reactions. Cities work the same way. The sheer frequency of encounters between people who would never otherwise meet produces combinations that no one, including the people involved, could have planned or predicted. New York’s density in the 1970s wasn’t merely a backdrop for the story of Fab Five Freddy and Blondie. It was a precondition for it. Remove the density, and the collision doesn’t happen. Remove the collision, and “Rapture” doesn’t exist.

But density does more than increase the frequency of encounters. It shortens the feedback loop between creation and response. An artist plays a show, gets a reaction, incorporates that reaction into the next performance, and plays again three nights later to a slightly different crowd in a slightly different room. The iteration cycle that might take years in a dispersed community takes weeks or months in a dense urban environment. That acceleration is what produces scenes rather than isolated artists. A scene requires not just talented people, but a critical mass of talented people in close enough proximity to challenge, inspire, and irritate one another regularly. The Harlem Renaissance needed Harlem. Hip-hop needed the Bronx. The London punk scene needed the specific geography of a few square miles of the inner city. These were not accidents of location. They were products of density doing its work.

Density cannot guarantee safety, however. Proximity produces friction, and friction can only happen when people feel secure bumping into one another. A collision between two people who don’t trust the space they’re in produces defensiveness rather than synthesis. Which is why the architecture of a place - its explicit values, its stated commitments, the signal it sends before anyone has played a note - matters as much as the density itself.

If you were to invent a temporary city, an ephemeral place where tens of thousands of people gather, creative friction intensifies in a safe environment, and expression flows like water, you might end up with something very much like Afropunk.

Cooper and Morgan insisted that everyone come correct. By making the space’s values explicit, they created an environment where people could show up authentically without fear. The result was a more vibrant temporary city, one where people felt safe enough to collide with one another and generate something new. What they were building, without necessarily calling it that, was the architecture of circulation.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/3a/95/3a957c06-c825-4057-9939-0a274cc16d23/content/images/2026/11/11-16-book-shot.jpg)

[***Circulation: How Culture Moves in the Age of Algorithm***](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1918661707?ref=hypebot.com), the new book from author and Co-Founder/President of **Thirty Tigers**, **David Macias**, is out **January 14** via **Whitefox Publishing**. Pre-order it [here.](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1918661707?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRedirect=mhFallback&ref=hypebot.com) 

The introduction and the first four chapters are also on [Substack](https://circulationbook.substack.com/) with no paywall.

[**Click here**](https://www.thirtytigers.com/about?ref=hypebot.com) **for more information on Thirty Tigers.** 

---

**David Macias* is a career music industry professional. He is Co-Founder and President of Thirty Tigers, a global music distribution, label services and management company, and has worked with an array clients including Lucinda Williams, Smashing Pumpkins, John Prine, Lupe Fiasco, Alanis Morissette and others. David is also a Grammy-award winning producer of historical music projects, having won for Beautiful Dreamer: The Songs Of Stephen Foster.*