Throws D.I.Y. Acts Royalty Bone
Thursday's Music 2.0 Briefing:, PirateBay, Japan's iPod Tax & More

Merlin Questions Royalty Program

Indie global rights body Merlin has issued a bulletin to it’s 12K members regarding’s new Artist Royalty Program. The organization is also considering legal action. Highlights of the bulletin:Merlin_logo_m_2

  • "The Program...does not appear to offer any compensation for any past illegal use of repertoire.  It is unclear to us whether or not the terms and conditions of the Program are intended to prevent master owners pursuing such compensation."
  • "...we have for the last few months been negotiating with regarding a non exclusive blanket license and a settlement agreement on behalf of Merlin members. Unfortunately, these negotiations have stalled -  in particular due to’s unwillingness to properly address its illegal infringing activity."
  • Several provisions of the licence terms and conditions of the Program appear ambiguous and open to legal interpretation. We note that this would tend to lead to uncertainty as to the “true” meaning of the licence. The licence points out that if you are unsure about any of it “YOU ARE ADVISED TO OBTAIN INDEPENDENT LEGAL ADVICE” - we would endorse that view.”

Merlin membership numbers over 12,000 labels representing the largest significant bundle of music rights outside the majors. It was created to serve as a much needed central indie music contact for digital, new media and web 2.0 rights. The deal is exactly what Merlin was formed to handle and the outcome could shape opinions of its effectiveness. Formed more than a year ago and formally staffed near the start of the yes, Merlin has yet to complete any significant rights negotiations.