3 Bottlenecks Holding Direct-To-Fan Marketing Back
By Jason Spitz (@jasonspitz), an e-commerce expert who helps bands, comedians, and other artists build direct-to-fan businesses.
1. Shopping Habits
"Artists who want to sell direct-to-fan must overcome this obstacle and convince their fans to shop via a method that is more cumbersome, takes longer, and is less reliable."
Those consumers also have pre-existing accounts with those services, so a purchase is as easy as a single mouse click, without having to type in a 16-digit credit card number. Artists who want to sell direct-to-fan must overcome this obstacle and convince their fans to shop via a method that is more cumbersome, takes longer, and is less reliable. But if the artist teaches fans to shop on their website, over time the fans’ behavior will shift.
2. Work Ethic
"Running a good store is hard work. It takes a lot
of time, energy, and attention. Many bands do not
have the work ethic, business savvy, or even the
time to run a good, efficient D2F store."
3. International Orders
Something I think isn't covered enough is that these services may work better in the USA where you have one currency, language, and infrastructure. In
Europe, you have a minefield of additional issues: language, currency rates, shipping, sales taxes, pan-European customer support — the list is pretty long
and presents a huge number of logistical problems.
For example, if I sell a product to someone in France, I may only be shipping from the UK, meaning huge
postage costs that might turn the fan off. If they do go ahead and buy and that product is then faulty in any way, the consumer then needs to return it —
which also means huge shipping costs. The problems can really mount up, and ultimately led to conclusions from many that it simply wasn't worth it.
Another
area I think doesn't get much coverage is how D2C factors into an artist's deal with their label (assuming they're signed of course). If the label are
running your D2C operation, they'll want a cut, and often that means the artist isn't seeing much more (if anything) back on the sales than usual. Equally,
the label may not either — and hence for them this can start to look like a lot of extra effort without significant additional returns to make it
worthwhile.
Some may respond to that referencing the value of CRM etc, I'd argue that all those marketing aspects can just as easily be handled without a
D2C product involved. If people are super fans, they'll sign up anyway.
—
This is Jason and Darren's response to sidewinder.fm's question:
Do you think that direct-to-fan marketing tools and services can reach their full-potential? What challenges or bottlenecks may have prevented these companies and their clients from getting there?
—
Sidewinder.fm is founded and edited by Kyle Bylin of Live Nation Labs. If you would like to contribute a post to be featured on the site, please reach out.
I think #2 is silly. If the work ethic isn’t there, musicians really aren’t that serious about their music as a career.
In other works, it’s not a bottleneck to the serious musicians who take their career seriously. It’s an opportunity that has never been there before.
Chris, you’re missing my point. Even serious, hardworking bands fail to maximize the full potential of D2F because they lack the time or business skills to run a successful, profitable D2F business. I certainly agree that D2F is a new opportunity, but its promise goes unfulfilled without A) the knowledge of how to run a profitable business, B) the time to devote to it, and C) the work ethic to really do it right. Most bands don’t have that combination of factors, even if they have 1 or 2 of them. They might sell some stuff D2F and make a little revenue, but they won’t build a profitable business off it.
I hear you on #3! It’s so hard to find a solution for artists that have equally distributed fan bases in more than one country. For artists looking to sell in Mexico and other Latin American countries, I do recommend Kichink though: https://www.kichink.com/
They have a cool set-up and they also partner with convenience stores so that fans can pay for their orders in cash. Another issue of D2F in some other countries being that a lot of people in Latin America don’t have credit cards.
Jason, I’ve got to agree with Chris on this one. Although I see you’re point too. Maybe you shouldn’t use the term ‘work ethic.’ You can have a killer work ethic but be working on the totally wrong things. I think what you’re really talking about is desire. The desire to treat your music as a small business. The desire to learn and to grow your business skills. I know a lot of people who work themselves to death but have not improved their skills in 20 years.