UPDATE 2 : A U.S. federal appeals court on Tuesday struck down key parts of the FCC's Open Internet rules, saying that the agency does not have the power to require internet service providers to treat all traffic equally. If upheld, the ruling could have a major effect on innovation in music online.
Most music tech startups deliver bandwidth heavy content including streaming video and music. If the ruling is upheld, ISP's, like Verizon who brought the suit, could charge for priority access. That would not only favor larger, deep pocketed players like Google, but also add an additional cost to tech and service providers already concerned with licensing costs.
Fine the ruling here.
Here is the official reaction from the Future Of Music Coalition
FUTURE OF MUSIC COALITION STATEMENT ON APPEALS COURT NET NEUTRALITY DECISION
WASHINGTON, DCâToday, a federal appeals court in Washington DC ruled that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) lacks the authority to enforce its Open Internet Order, issued in December 2010 and challenged by Verizon. The rules were established to prohibit Internet Service Providers (ISPs) from choosing winners and losers online based on business or other preferences. The court pointed out that the FCCâs lack of authority is a result of its decision in the early 2000s to reclassify broadband as an âinformation serviceâ as opposed to a âtelecommunications service.â
The following statement is attributed to Casey Rae, Interim Executive Director of Future of Music Coalition (FMC), a national non-profit research, education and advocacy organization for musicians.
âThe courtâs decision is disappointing, but not entirely unexpected. FMC has said since the beginning of the last decade that the FCCâs decision to classify broadband Internet as an information service would have poor consequences, and it doesnât get much worse than the inability to guarantee a level playing field for creators and other innovators.
âThe bright side is that the FCC, under the direction of newly-appointed chairman Tom Wheeler, now has the opportunity to fix a problem of its own making. It has never been more important to have basic rules of the road preventing ISPs from blocking content delivered over the Internet, regardless of how users connect. Thousands of musicians and independent labels are already on record in support of a level online playing field as part of FMCâs Rock the Net campaign. This decision will surely inspire countless other creators and entrepreneurs to make the case for an open and accessible Internet.
âOf course, Congress could always step up to the plate and write laws ensuring that the Internet remains a place where a great idea, a great song or an amazing innovation has a chance to get off the ground. Until then, the FCC has the obligation to act to protect all Americansâincluding creatorsâfrom the whims of just a few big corporations.â